I made pumpkin pie several weeks ago. I don’t remember the exact date, but I do remember that my second attempt at pumpkin pie was cracked on the top just as my first one had been. It had tasted fine, but the cracked custard was unsightly. Pumpkin pie should look smooth and unblemished on top.
I had a can of pumpkin puree sitting around on the shelf, and decided to use it the other day. I had intended to make pumpkin bread, but when my husband told me about some good news he’d received at work, I decided to make him a pumpkin pie to celebrate. He likes pumpkin pie, but it seems extravagant to make a pie for just two people. I recalled a pumpkin pie video I’d seen on chow.com, and set about to try it. Or at least use it as a basis.

making the pate sucree. Making dough is the only reason I'll break out the full-sized food processor now, since the parts take a while to clean by hand.
I made a number of adjustments to this recipe. I used a pate sucréee recipe from Martha Stewart that I’ve used many times before for tarte tatin and pie cookies. I considered trying my father-in-law’s fabulous flaky crust recipe, but I was making this after dinner, and knew it would take me more time to work through the less familiar recipe than one I’d used (almost) successfully in the past. I used canned pumpkin because I couldn’t be bothered with using a fresh pumpkin this time around. And I had to use a number of substitutions for spices – bay leaf instead of juniper berries, Tellicherry peppercorns instead of Sichuan, and a tablespoon of orange juice instead of orange peel. I don’t like the taste of licorice, and while I have whole star anise, I got it for making Chinese tea eggs. I didn’t bother with the walnut topping, knowing I’d be serving the pie with vanilla ice cream. I rarely enjoy nuts – too much chewing involved without enough flavour to justify it, in my opinion – and don’t often keep them around. I grant you that walnuts are some of the least offending nuts, thanks to their tender “meat” and high oil content, but since I am the cook here, I get final say.

attempt at making a pretty crust. failure.
I made the dough first, chilled it, and then rolled it out and tried to make a pretty edge design. Tried, that is. I then lined it with parchment paper and dumped a bunch of ceramic pie weights on top. When I first started cooking, I used dried kidney beans, because Emeril had recommended them as a cheap pie weight on one of his cooking shows. However, I have never cooked beans before, and would only keep them around as pie weights. I hated throwing them out after every crust, and after forgetting to buy them several times, decided to invest in ceramic pie weights. Recently, I had considered getting a pie chain from my kitchen supply catalog, since the cats enjoy playing with the beads and the dust they produce are a little messy, but held back. One note for future attempts is to cover the crust edges with foil to prevent browning.

ceramic pie weights nested in parchment paper.
Also, one bit of crust actually melted off the side within minutes, causing me to have to dive into the smoking oven with a paper towel. I had tried to build up the crust above the sides, since I knew that it would shrink with baking, but perhaps the height was too ambitious. Maybe I need a deeper pie dish? Thicker crust? Different recipe? More research required to say for certain.

not a clean pan

shiny, clean pan. Ahhh.
As for the custard, part of the reason for the delay in baking was that I refused to cook on what I considered to be a dirty pan. I could see clearly that it had been used to cook sausage with for vodka pasta, and I didn’t want any of that stuff to burn onto my spices for my ultra foodie pumpkin pie. I spent some time scrubbing it down with that green scrubber thing, warm water, and soap, and was rewarded with a shiny, clean little pan afterwards. I was good to go.

toasting spices in my shiny, clean pan. After a few seconds, I couldn't figure out why the bay leaf was in there, and removed it into the grinder cup

made to order, freshly toasted and ground pumpkin spices
I toasted the whole spices for 5 minutes, let them cool, then ground them in my Magic Bullet. I felt very foodie doing this. I put the freshly ground spice mix into a spare spice jar. It smelled nice. I peeled a lemon and minced the peel, which also smelled nice.

fresh plain brown egg in the middle and older, organic free run egg surrounding it (which is why it broke). Note how much darker the organic egg is compared to the lighter coloured generic kind
If given the choice, I prefer to buy farm fresh, organic, free range eggs. I don’t always do this for financial reasons, as the “good” eggs are three times the price of the cheap eggs. Michael Pollan’s gushing description of an all-natural farmer’s care of his grub-eating chickens in Botany of Desire started me off on this, but my own gastronomic experiences have confirmed them. While living in Providence, RI, I regularly bought a mix of eggs from my CSA (community-supported agriculture – a fun, weekly box of fresh produce from a local farmer) and then the weekly farmer’s market which included azuluna eggs. Those were my favourite, and would be the only enticement which could ever get me to set foot into an Evil Whole Foods, which also sold them when I couldn’t wait for market day. They had big, dark, creamy yolks and mine often had double yolks. Ohhhhh, they were amazing. Now that I’m cut off from my green eggs, I have to make do with buying those expensive brown eggs in the double fold plastic container in the organic section of the grocery store. In this picture, you can see clearly the colour difference between a more expensive egg and an inexpensive egg.

I opted to use my fancy, rainbow whisk to mix the custard.
I’d bought several cans of condensed milk for a different custard recipe involving squash, and was happy to use them for this case. I resorted to an online measurement converter in order to convert 14 fluid ounces into 414 ml into 1 3/4 cups. While the Joy of Baking had recommended not to overstir the custard, Mr. Portnoy instructed that it should be stirred well, which it was. I’d tried Joy of Baking the last time I had made pumpkin pie, which had cracked. There was leftover spice mix and leftover custard, which I stored although I doubt I’ll be able to use either.

beautiful, finished pumpkin pie. Note the burnt crust which didn't retain the pretty crimps I put into it- ugh.
Back in the pie went, and when it emerged after 50 minutes, I was happy to see that it was perfectly smooth and delicious-looking, except for the burnt parts of the crust. Unfortunately, that gorgeous surface was marred when I tested for doneness with a knife, twice to make sure. I let it cool for a bit, then served it with vanilla ice cream. I like how fresh the natural (Philadelphia-style) vanilla is compared to French-style. Almost as nice as freshly whipped cream.

midnight snack of pumpkin pie and vanilla ice cream.
It was almost midnight before we chowed down, but who cares? The spices and lemon zest really made a HUGE difference in flavour from preground spices. I couldn’t pick out all of the individual flavours, but they came together into a powerfully spicy and delicately herbal mixture. Though I can’t promise to toast and grind all my spices from now on – it’s a lot of trouble (i.e. a lot of extra dishes to clean and my poor Magic Bullet cup and grinder still smell like cinnamon) and I’m usually satisfied with just using preground spices for this sort of homey thing. But when I want to wow company, I will do this. The crust stayed crisp and it was easy to break off the burnt section around the edges. My husband approved. And I enjoyed another slice the next morning for breakfast, which still had a nice, crisp crust.